protest criminalization 2025 By the Editorial Desk – Citizen of Europe Published: July 27, 2025
“When protest becomes a risk, silence becomes a prison.”
With Donald Trump’s political resurgence and a surge of anti-protest legislation across U.S. states, dissenters—activists, students, and ordinary citizens—face mounting legal and financial risks, including criminal charges.
How likely is arrest for protest activity by 2035? Based on current trends, the risk appears to be increasing.
From Chilling Effect to Legal Threat
During Trump’s first term, large-scale protests faced significant crackdowns. Examples include the 2018 Women Disobey arrests and felony charges related to the 2017 DisruptJ20 protests. These events set a precedent for prosecuting protestors beyond traditional boundaries.
In 2025, states have introduced numerous bills tightening restrictions:
- According to the Brennan Center for Justice, at least 41 anti-protest bills were introduced in 22 states in 2025, surpassing the prior year’s total. (Brennan Center, 2025)
- Many target protests near infrastructure, university campuses, and anonymous activism.
- Proposed penalties include prison sentences of up to 20 years, asset freezes, and revocation of federal benefits or visas. (Portside, 2025)
Leaked Department of Homeland Security memos reported by The Guardian in July 2025 reveal surveillance of thousands of student activists linked to pro-Palestinian, environmental, and racial justice causes. (The Guardian, 2025)
Projected Risks of Protest Activity
Activity Legal Risk in 2025 Projected Risk by 2035 (If Current Trends Continue) Peaceful protest (march, rally) Low Moderate Civil disobedience (sit-ins, blockades) Moderate High Protesting near critical infrastructure Moderate to High Very High Campus protests (e.g., Palestine, climate) High Very High Organizing or funding protest efforts Moderate High (including potential RICO-style prosecutions) Protest by non-citizens or student visa holders High Extremely High
When Presence Equals Guilt
Over 200 protestors faced felony charges related to the 2017 DisruptJ20 events, though most were later dropped; this case established the precedent that mere presence could lead to prosecution. (The Independent, 2018)
In 2025, laws increasingly treat protests near pipelines or energy infrastructure as severe offenses, potentially carrying felony penalties.
DHS “Tiger Team” Surveillance of Student Activists
Leaked documents show the Department of Homeland Security’s formation of a “Tiger Team” monitoring over 5,000 student activists, focusing on pro-Palestinian, environmental, and racial justice groups. Consequences include visa revocations, frozen accounts, increased surveillance, and travel restrictions. (The Guardian, 2025)
One notable case: Columbia University student Mahmoud Khalil, a lawful permanent resident, was detained by ICE after organizing a teach-in, despite no formal charges being filed. (The Verge, 2025)
Global Implications for Europe
While these developments occur primarily in the United States, their repercussions extend internationally. European academics, NGOs, and students collaborating with U.S. activists risk surveillance and targeting via data sharing and cross-border law enforcement cooperation.
Solidarity activism is increasingly monitored and sometimes criminalized as subversive activity.
The Bottom Line: Rights Under Pressure
Protest remains legal but is increasingly restricted through legislation and surveillance.
If current trends persist:
- Arrests for symbolic or peaceful protest may become routine.
- Visa-based actions may silence international students and researchers.
- Financial penalties and ideological profiling may deter collective action.
The threat is not mass incarceration on a large scale, but the normalization of fear and self-censorship.
Did You Know?
Several U.S. states have enacted laws shielding drivers from liability if they injure protestors blocking roadways, effectively legalizing vehicular assaults under “anti-riot” statutes. (ACLU, 2025)
Legal Disclaimer
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Risk assessments are based on publicly available legislation and expert analysis as of July 2025. Legal outcomes depend on jurisdiction and individual circumstances.
You may like:The American Economy in 2025: Slow Growth, High Stakes, and Trump’s Gamble
About the Author
